"Horror movies usually aim to scare, entertain, and teach us. Amulet mostly does all three."
— Norman Gidney, Film Threat
"Amulet is deeply, deliberately mysterious, and all the more fun for it; the less viewers know going in, the more ferocious the ride."
— Fionnuala Halligan, Screen Daily
"The movie casts a grim sort of spell; a brooding, stifled dread that creeps in quietly from the margins, and lingers long after the last triumphant frame."
— Leah Greenblatt, Entertainment Weekly
"As a haunted house film, its ornate mythology pulls the dingy rotting rug out several times from under our initial idea of who is the haunter and who the hauntee."
— Jessica Kiang, The Playlist
"Amulet elevates these themes of repentance and sin through deft editing, strong performances, and a chilling score. It’s an evocative, confident debut, recalling the metaphorical horror of Jennifer Kent’s "The Babadook" or Babak Anvari’s "Under The Shadow," even as it announces the arrival of a singular new voice."
— Toussaint Egan, The A.V. Club