"Sultry, sinister, and wholly surprising."
— Nick Schager, The Daily Beast
"Eileen is a stylish and wild ride that never lets up."
— Murtada Elfadl, AV Club
"For all its heavy themes it's also a surprisingly funny movie, shot through with visual wit and off-kilter comedy."
— Leah Greenblatt, Entertainment Weekly
"McKenzie and Hathaway are superb as women subverting the prison of expectations — especially the viewer’s."
— Peter Howell, Toronto Star
"Offering beauty and strength in an oppressed and marginalized world, Eileen breaks the boundaries of perceived power."
— Sabina Dana Plasse, Film Threat
"The film is a pulpy phantasmagoria of fear and desire, offering visions of queer ecstasy within the confines of multiple prisons."
— Kyle Turner, Slant Magazine
"Oldroyd attacks with a pace that makes his plot twists more shocking and shows an economy that harks back to the golden age of noir."
— Screen Daily, Amber Wilkinson
"Oldroyd is clearly a master assembler of styles, but he never lets his vision outshine the wonderful central performances at the movie’s core."
— Ryan Lattanzio, IndieWire
"It’s both a tour de force for a cast led by Thomasin McKenzie and a sign that Oldroyd hasn’t lost his unsettling touch in the seven years since his last film."
— Steve Pond, TheWrap
"Eileen could not be more of a cross between the midcentury noir of Patricia Highsmith and Jim Thompson if Carol had conceived a child with The Killer Inside Me."
— Tim Robey, Daily Telegraph (UK)
"Rippling with sly humor and a bold command of the tropes of classic Hitchcockian suspense, this is a twisty and beguiling original, led by contrasting but expertly synced performances from Thomasin McKenzie and Anne Hathaway."
— David Rooney, The Hollywood Reporter
"If you loved the chaotic moxie Anne Hathaway brought to Colossal (Opens in a new window)or her campy femme fatale turn in the undersung Serenity, then you will absolutely scream as a rushed confession spills like red wine, dark and damning."
— Kristy Puchko, Mashable
"The formal rigor that made Oldroyd’s 'Lady Macbeth' such a striking debut is in evidence here throughout, but this time that directorial precision is applied to a narrative of bold, even garish ambition, which 'Eileen' conceals, along with its unhinged heart, beneath a controlled, placid exterior."
— Jessica Kiang, Variety