"A lively, engaging and moving documentary."
— Glenn Kenny, The New York Times
"More emotional than you'd expect from a doc about a hard-hitting catcher."
— Dan Fienberg, Hollywood Reporter
"The film is a spin through baseball history, but also an examination of how media-molded personas can overtake genuine accomplishments."
— Bill Goodykoontz, Arizona Republic
"I’m convinced. I’ll happily agree with what Billy Crystal says in the film, that Berra is 'the most overlooked superstar in the history of baseball.'"
— Daniel Neman, St. Louis Post-Dispatch
"Filled with game footage, home movies and knowledgeable talking heads, It Ain't Over ensures Berra’s exalted status in the annals of America’s pastime."
— Thelma Adams, AARP Movies for Grownups
"A warm-hearted look back at one of professional sport’s most colourful folk heroes, the late Yogi Berra, the documentary, It Ain’ Over, is also a film with a score to settle."
— Liam Lacey, Original-Cin
"Yogi Berra lived the kind of life we wish our heroes to have: filled with love, respect, and integrity. This is a film fans can embrace and younger generations can learn from. I loved it."
— Leonard Maltin, leonardmaltin.com
"Sean Mullin’s documentary It Ain’t Over is literally inside baseball. The film is essentially a Berra family project, an attempt to rehabilitate the professional reputation of someone who often doesn’t get his due as a player."
— G. Allen Johnson, San Francisco Chronicle
"This is the kind of movie that makes you want to sit through the credits, and not for some “hidden” scene featuring superheroes eating shawarma. Rather, it’s because it’s so pleasant you won’t want It Ain’t Over to be over."
— Mike Scott, New Orleans Times-Picayune
"Serving as a potent reminder of the stellar athletic ability that, in time, had been overshadowed by his admittedly outsized personality, the affectionate It Ain’t Over offers a winning coda to the career assessment of the late, great Yogi Berra."
— Michael Rechtshaffen, Los Angeles Times