"Alternately satirical and romantic, full of pain and humor, Buffalo '66 is a winner."
— Kevin Thomas, Los Angeles Times
"All bets are off. For my money, Vincent Gallo wins the Triple Crown of indie filmmaking -- for writing, directing and starring in Buffalo '66."
— Bob Graham, San Francisco Chronicle
"Gallo's directorial debut is one of a kind, an eccentric, provocative comedy which laces a poignant love story with both a sombre, washed-out naturalism and surreal musical vignettes."
— Tom Charity, Time Out
"It's all somehow both familiar and dazzling, just as Ricci's kidnapped tap student, forced to pose as the protagonist's wife for his horrifically indifferent parents, is somehow both nondescript and heartbreaking."
— Entertainment Weekly
"This says nothing about Gallo's own demonic charm as Billy or his directorial boldness in juxtaposing the emotional surreality of his story with the bleak reality of his hometown in winter, creating a sort of casual but strangely haunting weirdness."
— Richard Schickel, Time