"A warmhearted comedy and a classic baseball movie."
— Richard Roeper, Chicago Sun-Times
"Under Penny Marshall's spirited, warm direction, the players shine."
— Duane Byrge, Hollywood Reporter
"One of [1991's] most cheerful, most relaxed, most easily enjoyable comedies."
— Vincent Canby, New York Times
"A League of Their Own is as exhilarating as a double- header at Chicago's Wrigley Field."
— Jackie Potts, Miami Herald
"It’s a great piece of Hollywood confectionery, and you might well find yourself choking up a little at the end."
— Peter Bradshaw, Guardian
"A League of Their Own is a grand-slam comic drama. Superbly written, acted and directed. [1 July 1992, p.1D]"
— Hal Lipper, Tampa Bay Times
"Hardly a perfect film, League nonetheless represents a breakthrough in women's sports movies: It's a celebration of sport for sport's sake."
— Jill Rachlin, Entertainment Weekly
"The story of the short-lived women's baseball league gives Marshall the opportunity to examine the roots of modern feminism and have a darn fine time doing it."
— Kathleen Maher, Austin Chronicle
"Graced by Davis and enlivened by Lovitz and the ensemble cast, it sends us home feeling a little higher, with visions of peanuts and Cracker Jack floating in our heads."
— Rita Kempley, Washington Post
"It's a mostly winning combination of sassy humour and sentiment, enlivened by some fun "newsreel" recreations that catch the period flavour of a sport adopting showbiz tactics - flirty-skirted uniforms, cheesecake stunts and skin-scraping do-or-die game plays - to attract the crowds."
— Angie Errigo, Empire
"Marshall treats everything, from the feminist themes to a soundtrack that features period chestnuts redone by contemporary singers, with a unique mix of the furiousand the subdued - a broad knee-slapper one moment, a delicate caress the next. No wonder we root for it. With the count full and our hopes wavering, A League Of Their Own smacks a stand-up triple and dares us not to cheer. Go ahead - give in and be a fan."
— RIck Groen, The Globe and Mail (Toronto)