"It’s impossible not to be won over."
— Stephen Saito, Variety
"Captures the artistry, ingenuity and humor of its subject better than an encyclopedic history ever could."
— Luke Hicks, Little White Lies
"Splicing together real archival video, fake documentary footage about the making of a fake biopic, and real conversations with the present-day band, Pavements is delightfully chaotic."
— Sasha Geffen, Sasha Geffen NPR
"A thrillingly creative music documentary that serves as a loving tribute to the band. The sense of fun that Alex Ross Perry is having behind the camera is both palpable and infectious."
— Matthew Turner, NME (New Musical Express)
"A tip of the hat for the underground heroes and a beautiful, outright creative portrait of their essence, the slacker repertoire, and the music world they shaped one shrouded pop record at a time."
— Hector A. Gonzalez, InSession Film
"A reminder that the fourth (and fifth and sixth) wall can be smashed, that the rock doc can be reinvented. And that when the message is meta for meta’s sake, why not make the medium that way, too?"
— Adam Solomons, Indiewire
"In an age of musical biopic plenty, this semi-ironic, postmodern take — which runs through Perry's part drama, part documentary, and part mockumentary — may be just what the doctor ordered."
— Siddhant Adlakha, Mashable
"Beavis & Butthead (hilariously) suggested Pavement needed to 'try harder.' You certainly can’t lob that criticism at Alex Ross Perry, who crafts a mock-biopic, art installation and jukebox musical all in service of a heartfelt documentary tribute."
— Adam Kempenaar, Filmspotting
"A joyous, slyly subversive celebration that, while unlikely to persuade newcomers to the music, nevertheless catches the band’s wayward spirit, as well as the downright ordinariness that came as an alternative to the bloated rock band ethos."
— Jonathan Romney, Screen International