"It’s still an absolutely fascinating watch."
— David Fear, Rolling Stone
"A documentary that dares to question everything, including itself."
— Adam Kempenaar, Filmspotting
"A raw and riveting documentary that skeptically re-examines the program’s appeal, legacy, and ethicality."
— David Ehrlich, IndieWire
"Tonally, this steady and powerful film is everything the original program wasn’t: hesitant, sorrowful and compassionate for every human being onscreen."
— Amy Nicholson, Los Angeles Times
"David Osit’s trenchant documentary recognizes that To Catch a Predator sold humiliation as entertainment in the guise of legitimizing law-and-order punitivism."
— Derek Smith, Slant Magazine
"Apart from anything else, Predators is a clinic in documentary ethics, but Osit’s intellect doesn’t mute his pain, sensitivity and outrage. It’s a film for the heart and the head."
— Scott Tobias, The Reveal
"Osit’s brilliant, subtly needling film leaves us unnerved and alert, but not certain of our convictions -- an outcome, perhaps, that more true-crime programming should pursue."
— Guy Lodge, Variety
"Initially teasing a condemnation, only to come away with something less certain and more fascinating, it straddles various lines, and perspectives, with impressive confidence."
— Nick Schager, The Daily Beast