"This is who Almodóvar is as a filmmaker. His work is filled with sumptuous treats all in service of stories that challenge. In his hands, the trickiest subjects go down smooth."
— Drew Gregory, Autostraddle
"The richly acted, sumptuously photographed Strange Way of Life lives up to its title as a revisionist Western that embraces its classical genre roots while also carving out a very modern way of looking at the past."
— Stephen Garrett, Observer
"It’s a provocative movie that brings out the best in both of its leads, and feels like the filmmaker is having fun playing around with these genre tropes, even if he’s not being the least bit ironic in his use of them."
— David Fear, Rolling Stone
"The filmmaking, as you’d expect, is impeccable, Almodóvar’s regular composer Alberto Iglesias providing menace and melodrama in equal measure, only giving into Morricone-esque operatic stylings over the end credits."
— Ian Freer, Time Out