"Lovingly designed, impeccably stylish and heartwarming."
— Michael Wilmington, Chicago Tribune
"It's funny, touching and beautifully paced with numerous examples of the celebrated 'Lubitsch touch'."
— Philip French, The Observer (UK)
"Close to perfection--one of the most beautifully acted and paced romantic comedies ever made in this country."
— Pauline Kael, The New Yorker
"This 1940 film is one of Ernst Lubitsch's finest and most enduring works, a romantic comedy of dazzling range."
— Dave Kehr, Chicago Reader
"The onscreen chemistry between James Stewart and Margaret Sullivan was the stuff of legend, never better displayed than in this Ernst Lubitsch romantic charmer."
— Kenneth Turan, Los Angeles Times
"This may be the best romantic comedy ever made. The great Ernst Lubitsch handles his 'small' theme brilliantly, bringing the lives of everyday people to the screen as he had never done before."
— TV Guide Magazine
"The real surprise is in how earnestly the director of some of the finest, spikiest romantic comedies ever made is willing to step off the gas and let heartfelt romance win the day. And it so very winning."
— Kimberley Jones, Austin Chronicle
"For my money, this is Lubitsch’s masterpiece, an immaculate conflation of his sprightly shooting style, expertly layered wisecracking and bracing realism, all topped off with a romantic subplot that offers a nakedly joyous celebration of young, serendipitous love."
— Time Out
"Samson Raphaelson's marvel of a script unfolds in six sequences that rise and fall with the surprising weight of mini-lifetimes; under Lubitsch's tart-tender direction, the emotionally transparent Stewart and the electric, conflicted Sullivan create an immortal comic courtship."
— Michael Sragow, Baltimore Sun